Why monkeys are driving India's smart-city planners nuts
April 21, 2015
As India launches an $18bn smart-cities plan to spread the information revolution to its provinces, the problems it faces are a holdover from the past – electricity shortages, badly planned, jam-packed cities, and monkeys.
The clash between the old world and the new is sharply in focus in the crowded 3000-year-old holy city of Varanasi, where many devout Hindus come to die in the belief that doing so will give them salvation. Varanasi is also home to hundreds of macaque monkeys that live in its temples and are fed and venerated by devotees. But the monkeys also feast on the fibre-optic cables that are strung along the banks of the Ganges river.
"We cannot move the temples from here," said communications engineer AP Srivastava. “We cannot modify anything here, everything is built up. The monkeys, they destroy all the wires and eat all the wires.”
Srivastava, who oversees the expansion of new connections in the local district, said his team had to replace the riverside cables when the monkeys chewed them up less than two months after they were installed. He said his team was now looking for alternatives, but there are few to be found.
The city of over two million people is impossibly crowded and laying underground cable is out of the question. Chasing away or trapping the monkeys will outrage residents and temple-goers.
Varanasi is part of the parliamentary constituency of prime minister Narendra Modi, a Hindu nationalist leader who came to power last May.
A shortage of electricity is further complicating efforts to set up stable Wifi in public places – daily power cuts can last for hours during the sweltering summer in Varanasi and across much of India. Modi's government has pledged to lay 700,000km of broadband cable to connect India's 250,000 village clusters within three years, build 100 new smart cities by 2020 and shift more public services such as education and health to electronic platforms to improve access and accountability. Varanasi was the first of an eventual 2500 locations singled out for street-level Wifi.
Industry experts predict that the broadband initiative, along with a surge in smartphone ownership, will mean about a third of Indians will have access to the internet by 2017, from about 20 per cent, or 250 million people, now. Expanding internet connectivity and making access cheaper could add up to 1.6 percentage points, or about $70bn, to India's GDP over a four-year period, consultants at McKinsey have estimated.
Global technology companies see opportunity in Modi's commitment to a digital future and are adapting their products to India's varied climates and external threats.
IBM is in discussions to provide software to help several cities make the leap into the digital age. Network provider Cisco Systems is working with the government in the eastern city of Visakhapatnam to bring more education and healthcare services online, and has developed a ruggedised Wifi box to survive India's varied climates and cut down on the need for cables that will be at the mercy of the elements –- or monkeys.
"We've built outdoor Wifi-access routers specifically keeping in mind Indian environmental conditions," Dinesh Malkani, Cisco's India country head, said in an interview. "You cannot predict what challenges you are going to come up against."
Bringing some order to India's chaotic cities with technology is a daunting task. India's urban population is forecast to swell by an additional 220 million to 600 million by 2031, potentially overwhelming already inadequate infrastructure.
Many of the new digital projects are simply aimed at improving existing civic amenities: time traffic information to help people better plan their journey, or systems that allow individuals to monitor water leakages or waste management and then inform local authorities.
Vinod Kumar Tripathi, an urban planning expert in Varanasi, said Modi's initiatives needed to be coupled with huge investments in improving basic services such as housing, roads and waste management.
"Everything here is old, outdated and the population pressure just makes it worse," Tripathi said in his office overlooking the Banaras Hindu University. “This place was a small temple town and is now a commercial centre.”
The free Wifi service that started in February is certainly stimulating the consumer economy. Boatman Sandeep Majhi makes a living ferrying pilgrims and bereaved families who scatter ashes in the river after performing cremations. He recently purchased his first smartphone to download music and exchange videos with friends, and promote his boat business to tourists on Facebook.
But he said the government needed to pay equal attention to the municipal services in a city where cars, rickshaws and carts fight for space through narrow, potholed roads lined with litter. Varanasi remains dependent on a 500-year-old, leaky drainage system for its sewage.
"Free Wifi is a good facility for tourists but I think the officials should think about cleaning the ghats," said the 20-year-old, referring to the steps down to the river, which are often caked with cow dung.